Stewards of the Past - The Weston Schoolhouse

Penny Carlton • August 12, 2025

Stewards of the Past - The Weston Schoolhouse

Weston Schoolhouse, a beloved landmark situated near Keuka Lake, is set for rejuvenation, driven by the commitment of a dedicated nonprofit organization and an upcoming community fundraiser.


The Friends of Weston Schoolhouse have announced a four-day Antique and Vintage Yard Sale, scheduled from Thursday, August 14 to Sunday, August 17, on the grounds of the historic one-room Weston Schoolhouse along County Road 23, Weston Schoolhouse can be found at 463 County Road 23 on the corner of Bailey Hill Road. This event will align with the Waneta Lake Community Yard Sales, offering an opportunity for residents and visitors to explore unique treasures while supporting local preservation efforts.


As guardians of the Weston Schoolhouse, the Friends of Weston Schoolhouse are passionately committed to its preservation. Nestled in the charming community of Tyrone, NY, this historic one-room schoolhouse, built between 1840 and 1870, holds a special place in Schuyler County, situated between Lamoka and Waneta Lakes. For more than seventy years, eager students learned within its walls until its closure around 1940, when the rural schools in the area were consolidated. Subsequently, students from Weston Schoolhouse were transferred to Bradford Central School.


Designated a historic site on the National Register of Historic Places in 1998, this designation reflects the dedicated efforts of Jean Hubsch, who managed The Mustard Seed Attic, which functioned in the former schoolhouse until August 2024. Currently, the Town of Tyrone is transferring stewardship of the Weston Schoolhouse to the Friends of Weston Schoolhouse. This passionate group of history advocates is spearheading a restoration project driven by community donations, volunteer work, and material support.


Several local businesses have already shown their support: Finger Lakes Metal generously provided a new roof at no cost, Knapp & Schlappi contributed lumber, and Bruder Brothers Construction offered half the labor for recent repairs. Despite these promising strides, considerable work lies ahead—especially regarding the building’s foundation and its aging north wall. 


Looking ahead, the group envisions the revitalized schoolhouse as a significant historical landmark and a vibrant community hub. Their mission is to safeguard and celebrate the history not just of Weston, but of the entire town of Tyrone. The schoolhouse is set to transform into a museum, recreating the interior of a late 19th to early 20th century school. The walls will showcase exhibits that illuminate the geological formation of the Lamoka-Waneta area, the indigenous peoples, the westward expansion following the Revolutionary War and the War of 1812, as well as the early industry and commerce of Tyrone. 


The museum will feature an “open concept” design for half of its space, accommodating groups for meetings, crafting workshops, and serving as a hub for community gatherings. The primary aim is to create a venue that fosters social interaction and encourages community engagement, all while honoring Tyrone’s rich history and the treasured one-room schoolhouse.


Volunteers are always welcome! Membership in the Friends of Weston Schoolhouse is open to everyone. For more information, feel free to reach out via email. In the meantime, rally some friends and join in this weekend for an extraordinary fundraising yard sale experience! 


By Penny Carlton May 22, 2026
The Tailgate Market: A New Kind of Community Gathering Along Route 415
By Penny Carlton May 21, 2026
Beyond the Wine The Quiet Agriculture That Still Feeds Keuka
By Penny Carlton May 20, 2026
The Strowbridge Tragedy A Buried Horror in the Hills Above Keuka
By Penny Carlton May 19, 2026
When Keuka Danced The Barn Dance Era
By Penny Carlton May 18, 2026
The Final Chapter of Aisle of Pines The Murders at the Gatehouse
By Penny Carlton May 15, 2026
Friday Night Fever: 🔥 When the School Buses Go Rogue at Outlaw Speedway 🚍
By Penny Carlton May 14, 2026
Milly’s Market & Cafe Re-Opening Brings a Beautiful Day of Community to Main Street Penn Yan
By Penny Carlton May 13, 2026
When the Familiar Voices Go Quiet  A Reflection on Dave Taylor Smith, Casandre Wilcox, Local Radio & the Communities Left Behind
By Penny Carlton May 12, 2026
The Aisle of Pines  The Mystical Mansion That Once Watched Over Keuka & Waneta Lakes
By Penny Carlton May 11, 2026
Where the Roots Still Remain: The Story of the Wagener Estate
Show More