Apparently, Stanley cups have been holding out on us!

Penny Carlton • September 30, 2026

🍦 STUFF YOUR STANLEY IS BACK!

🍦 STUFF YOUR STANLEY IS BACK!

Five scoops. Ten bucks. One very happy Stanley. 😋


Apparently, Stanley cups have been holding out on us.


Sure, they can keep your coffee hot and your water cold—but around Keuka, we’ve discovered their true calling.


ICE CREAM. Lots and lots of ice cream. 🍦😂


On Sunday, October 18, Seneca Farms in Penn Yan is bringing back Stuff Your Stanley after its spring event proved so popular that, well… they simply had to do it again.


And the deal?


🍨 FIVE SCOOPS OF HOMEMADE ICE CREAM FOR JUST $10!


Yes. Five. Scoops.


Bring your clean Stanley—or any Stanley-style insulated cup—and Seneca Farms will stuff that baby with homemade ice cream.

Chocolate? Vanilla? Something a little more adventurous?


We’re not judging.


Frankly, once you put five scoops in a Stanley, you've already committed to the adventure. 😂


BUT DOES IT REALLY WORK?


This is the question I had.


Because five scoops is not exactly a casual little ice cream cone.


But I heard from some very reliable sources that yes, it absolutely works.


During the last Stuff Your Stanley event, people were reportedly still enjoying their ice cream at 9 PM!


Now that is putting Stanley insulation to important work.


Forget keeping your drink cold.


We have entered the era of portable, all-day ice cream. 😂🍦


🍁 A PERFECT LITTLE FALL ROAD TRIP


October around Keuka means colorful leaves, crisp air, pumpkins, sweaters…and apparently five scoops of ice cream.


Sounds perfectly reasonable to us.


Make a little day of it. Take the scenic drive into Penn Yan, enjoy the fall colors, and stop at Seneca Farms for one of those wonderfully quirky local events that makes living around the Crooked Lake so much fun.


🍦 STUFF YOUR STANLEY — THE DETAILS


Sunday, October 18
⏰ 10:30 AM–9 PM
📍 Seneca Farms
2485 State Route 54A
Penn Yan, NY 14527


$10 = 5 scoops of homemade ice cream


Bring your clean Stanley or Stanley-style cup, ready to be stuffed!


And here's our only question:


What FIVE scoops are going in yours? 👀🍦


Tell us in the comments—because some of us need to begin developing our ice cream strategy immediately.


Stay Rooted. Stay Keuka.™

Small Towns. Big Stories. One Crooked Lake.™


Join our FB Group Keuka Roots


By Penny Carlton • September 28, 2026
OUT OF THE DARKNESS Walking Together Toward Hope on Keuka Lake
By Penny Carlton • September 17, 2026
FINALE | WINGS & WHEELS: A HOMECOMING FOR HISTORY  For a Little While, Walk in Glenn Curtiss’ Footsteps
By Penny Carlton • September 15, 2026
KEUKA LAKE: AN EARLY LABORATORY OF NAVAL AVIATION  Where Seaplanes Learned to Conquer the Water
By Penny Carlton • September 11, 2026
WHEN THE NAVY CAME TO HAMMONDSPORT  The Village That Helped Teach America’s Navy to Fly
By Penny Carlton • September 10, 2026
DID PENN YAN PUT THE “BASKET” IN BASKETBALL?  Before There Was Basketball: The Penn Yan Peach Basket Mystery
By Penny Carlton • September 8, 2026
Part Four | FROM WHEELS TO WINGS Glenn Curtiss, the AEA, and the Moment Everything Left the Ground
By Penny Carlton • September 4, 2026
Save the Cupola: A Piece of Our Past. A Beacon for Our Future.
By Penny Carlton • September 3, 2026
ROAD TO WINGS & WHEELS Part Three | G.H. AND THE AUTOMOBILE
By Penny Carlton • September 2, 2026
🍎 Fall Just Got a Little Sweeter at Wager’s Cider Mill
By Penny Carlton • September 1, 2026
LABOR DAY WEEKEND AROUND KEUKA Pick a Town. Pick an Adventure!
Show More