A Personal Review of Oak Hill

Penny Carlton • October 23, 2025

Oak Hill - My Happy Place

A Keuka Roots Review


There are places you visit, and then there are places you return to again and again—because they feel like home. For me, that place is Oak Hill Bulk Foods. Nestled along Route 14A in Penn Yan, this family-founded gem is a celebration of good food, warm smiles, and the timeless charm of the Finger Lakes.


A Little History Behind the Charm


Oak Hill Bulk Foods isn’t just a store—it’s a story built on vision, faith, and hard work. Founded in 1983 by Amos and Fannie Stoltzfus, it began right in the front room of their home, where they sold dry goods and baking staples to neighbors.


What started as a small idea grew into something much bigger: a gathering place, a part of daily life for the Penn Yan community. By 1990, Oak Hill had expanded into its current home, a welcoming store that still carries the same heart it was founded with.


As I wandered through the aisles, I could almost picture those early days—Amos and Fannie greeting neighbors by name, stocking shelves with care, and slowly building a space that would become a Finger Lakes favorite.


A Shopper’s Paradise


Inside, Oak Hill is a feast for the senses. Rows of bulk grains, colorful candies, and old-fashioned baking staples line the shelves, each one inviting you to slow down and explore.

The air is rich with the scent of roasted coffee and warm bread—an irresistible lure that led me straight to the café.


Lunch was simple and perfect: a crisp chicken salad sandwich on freshly baked bread, paired with a steaming bowl of homemade soup fragrant with herbs. It tasted like comfort, like something your grandmother might make on a chilly afternoon.


Then came my favorite part—the sample bar, which changes weekly to highlight Oak Hill’s specials. That day’s offerings were a cheese lover’s dream: sharp cheddars, nutty Swiss, and creamy Havarti. The friendly staff encouraged me to try them all, and I happily obliged.


And, of course, I couldn’t leave without a visit to the bakery. Rows were filled with cookies, pastries, and the famous Fry Pies—golden, flaky, fruit-filled pockets of pure joy. I tried a bite of each bakery good on the sample counter  (it would’ve been rude not to!) and tucked a few Fry Pies in my basket for later.


Everywhere I turned, there was something new to discover—homemade jams, pickles, local honey, and rows of freshly roasted coffee beans that perfumed the air. Oak Hill doesn’t just invite you to shop; it invites you to linger.


More Than a Market


What makes Oak Hill special goes beyond the food. It’s the feeling you get the moment you walk in—the genuine smiles, the sense of belonging, the little conversations that remind you that community still matters.


You can sense the Stoltzfus family’s legacy everywhere: in the way the staff greets you, in the quality of every product, and in the quiet pride that fills the space. Oak Hill isn’t just a store—it’s a reminder of what can grow when heart and hard work come together.


As I left, my bag a little heavier and my spirit a little lighter, I realized that Oak Hill isn’t simply a stop along Route 14A—it’s a destination. One that keeps calling you back.


Planning Your Visit

📍 Oak Hill Bulk Foods
14A Penn Yan, NY
🕰️ Open Monday–Saturday (check hours before visiting)
☕ Don’t miss: the café lunch specials, sample bar, and Fry Pies!


If you find yourself exploring the Finger Lakes, make a point to stop at Oak Hill. Whether you’re picking up bulk staples, enjoying a homemade meal, or just soaking in the down-home charm, this little gem is a true taste of what makes our region special.


Until next time around Keuka. 🌿

By Penny Carlton November 3, 2025
A story of faith, friendship, and fresh food — where community spirit turned a question into something extraordinary.
By Penny Carlton October 31, 2025
A Night of Spooks, Smiles & Small-Town Magic
By Penny Carlton October 31, 2025
Penn Yan’s Fall Festival:  Where Community, Color & Cheer Come Together
By Penny Carlton October 30, 2025
Where the Lake Remembers
By Penny Carlton October 29, 2025
Shop, sip, snap, and savor the last golden days of the season
By Penny Carlton October 28, 2025
From craft beers to canine companions, this Penn Yan gem proves that when community and creativity meet, everyone leaves a little happier.
By Penny Carlton October 27, 2025
Thunder in Their Hearts: The Power of Community, Commitment, and Softball
By Penny Carlton October 27, 2025
Stage Lights and Small-Town Magic:  PYTCo Shines in Penn Yan
By Penny Carlton October 25, 2025
“When gratitude turns into giving, a community shines brighter.” As I was scrolling through Facebook last night, I came across a post from Lauren McQuaid, owner of Simplicity on Main , that truly touched my heart. Her words carried such warmth, gratitude, and purpose that I felt compelled to share them — not only to help her spread the word, but to celebrate the kindness that makes our community so special. There’s a quiet kind of beauty in kindness — the kind that radiates from people who use what they have to make the world just a little bit better. Here in Penn Yan, that beauty shines brightly through Lauren McQuaid, owner of Simplicity on Main, a women’s clothing boutique that has become more than just a place to shop. It’s a space where confidence, connection, and community come together — and this season, Lauren is weaving those values into something even more meaningful. A Giving Spirit Lauren believes in gratitude in action. As she says so simply, “ When you’ve been blessed with a large platform, you need to do as much good with it as possible.” With the holidays fast approaching — a time of joy, reflection, and often, struggle — Lauren wanted to find a way to lift up those in need right here in Penn Yan. Over the next several weeks, Simplicity on Main will be collecting unexpired pantry goods for a local charity that serves families in our own community. Anyone wishing to donate can drop items off during the boutique’s regular business hours. And, as a sweet token of appreciation, the first 25 people who contribute will receive a small thank-you gift from Lauren and her team — a gesture that reflects the generosity and heart that define her shop. Style with Purpose Since opening her doors, Lauren has created more than a boutique — she’s created a gathering place. A place where women come not only to find beautiful clothes, but to feel seen, celebrated, and encouraged. Her belief that “nobody should ever go without” extends far beyond fashion; it’s woven into the very fabric of her business. Whether it’s through a smile, a compliment, or this latest community project, Lauren continues to remind us that style isn’t just about what we wear — it’s about how we show up for one another. The Heart of Penn Yan Penn Yan’s charm comes from its people — the small business owners, volunteers, and everyday neighbors who quietly make a difference. Lauren’s giving initiative is one more reason our visitors often say, “You can feel something special here.” It’s true — in our little village, kindness isn’t rare. It’s part of who we are. So as you stroll down Main Street this season, stop into Simplicity on Main. Browse the racks, say hello, and if you can, drop off a donation. Because when we come together — one can, one act of kindness, one heart at a time — we make Penn Yan shine just a little brighter. ❤️ Thank you, Lauren, for reminding us what it means to lead with grace, gratitude, and community spirit. 🛍️ Visit Simplicity on Main Let’s do what we do best, Penn Yan! ❤️ Weekly Hours: Monday: 9 AM – 3 PM Tuesday: Closed Wednesday: 9 AM – 3 PM Thursday: 9 AM – 3 PM Friday: 9 AM – 5 PM Saturday: 10 AM – 3 PM Sunday: Closed Address: 📍 1 E Main Street, Penn Yan, NY (The old bookstore on the corner of Main and Water St!) Join Lauren and Simplicity on Main on FB
By Penny Carlton October 24, 2025
Fall magic, handmade treasures,  and a little Halloween mischief!
Show More