Spooktacular Saturday at The Windmill Farm & Craft Market

Penny Carlton • October 24, 2025

Fall magic, handmade treasures,

and a little Halloween mischief!

There’s something about late October that feels like a spell — the air tingles with change, the hillsides glow in pumpkin and copper, and everything seems touched by just a hint of magic. This Saturday, I’m following that feeling straight to The Windmill Farm & Craft Market for their Halloween celebration!


I can already imagine it: the crunch of leaves underfoot, the scent of cider and cinnamon swirling through the Windmill, and that joyful hum of people bundled in sweaters, sipping something warm, and smiling at the simple wonder of it all. The Windmill always feels special — but at Halloween? It’s downright enchanting.


🧙‍♀️ Witches Take the Stage


I’m especially excited to see the Witches of the Southern Tier!


They’ll be dancing through the market in all their spooky, sparkly glory — brooms in hand, capes flowing, and plenty of mischief in the air. I’ve heard they bring laughter, rhythm, and just enough “hocus pocus” to make you forget you’re not actually in a storybook.


I plan to grab a mug of hot cider and find a good viewing spot — because something tells me their performance will be the highlight of the day.


🍬 Tricks, Treats, and Market Magic


And yes, there’s trick-or-treating!


The Windmill’s vendors will be handing out goodies, and I can’t wait to see all the little ghosts, goblins, and giggling pumpkins wander from shop to shop collecting sweets. There’s something so heartwarming about seeing families together — kids in costumes, parents with cameras, everyone laughing and just… being present. It’s small-town Halloween at its very best.


📸 Fall Photo Contest Fun


You know I’ll have my camera ready! The Windmill is a photographer’s dream this time of year — bright pumpkins stacked high, handmade fall décor in every corner, and that perfect golden glow that only autumn can create.


I’m planning to snap a few photos for The Windmill’s Fall Photo Contest, too. (If you haven’t heard — they’re offering prizes and a feature on KeukaRoots.com!). I’ll probably end up taking way too many pictures, but really, can you have too much fall magic?


🍁 Making a Day of It


My plan is simple: wander, sip, smile, repeat. I’ll start with a pumpkin donut and coffee, linger over the handcrafted treasures, watch the witches dance, and maybe pick up a few early Christmas gifts — because honestly, who can resist those cozy candle booths and handmade goodies?


Days like this are what autumn in the Finger Lakes is all about — community, creativity, and just enough whimsy to make you feel like a kid again.


📅 When & Where


🗓 This Saturday, October 25
🕗
8:00 AM – 4:30 PM
📍
The Windmill Farm & Craft Market
3900 NY-14A, Penn Yan, NY
💲
Free Admission!

🧙‍♀️ Witches of the Southern Tier performance at 12:30 PM
🍬
Trick-or-Treating fun throughout the market


I’ll be there — camera in hand, sweater on, and probably a cinnamon-sugar smile plastered across my face. If you see me wandering between the barns, stop and say hello… after all, it’s not every Saturday you get to spend the day surrounded by pumpkins, laughter, and a little Halloween magic. 




The Windmill

By Penny Carlton April 6, 2026
The Switz — Where the Lake Still Remembers
By Penny Carlton April 3, 2026
⛽ A Gallon for Seventeen Cents The Story of Shay Oil Company, Penn Yan (1924)
By Penny Carlton April 2, 2026
Where the Music Carried Across the Docks Remembering The Waterfront  A Keuka Lake Gathering Place
By Penny Carlton April 2, 2026
The Hidden Cork Where Stories, Sips, and New Beginnings Meet in Hammondsport
By Penny Carlton April 1, 2026
When a Joke Became a Legacy: The Story of Tyrtle Beach From a radio joke to a lakeside legacy—where one brave jump turned into generations of giving.
By Penny Carlton March 31, 2026
Breweries Around Keuka Lake: From Hop Fields to Craft Beer  Discover the Finger Lakes Craft Beer Scene from Penn Yan to Hammondsport
By Penny Carlton March 30, 2026
The Pleasant Valley Inn: A Quiet Piece of Keuka’s Wine Country History Exploring the historic Hammondsport Inn along Pleasant Valley Road where Finger Lakes wine country travelers have gathered for generations
By Penny Carlton March 30, 2026
Why Visit Keuka?  Because No Other Lake Spells Y Like This
By Penny Carlton March 26, 2026
Chasing Flowers at the Finger Lakes Produce Auction
By Penny Carlton March 25, 2026
🌿 A New Chapter on Pulteney Street 74 Pulteney Street, Hammondsport Dockside Wine & Spirits
Show More