There are shops that you simply shop in… and then there are places that feel stitched into
the fabric of your life, your community, and your sense of home. For me, The Nest Egg in downtown Penn Yan has always been one of those rare places — the kind where memories linger between the shelves just as warmly as the lights glimmering above them.
I can still remember the first time I stepped through its doors — long before social media, long before the village revitalized into the bustling storybook Main Street we know today. I was in Penn Yan for a short visit, sometime in the early 90s, and The Nest Egg, established in 1988, had already earned its place as a small-town gem. Even then, it had that unmistakable charm: part gift shop, part treasure chest, part cozy nook where time seemed to slow down the moment you walked in.
Tucked right at 120 Main Street, Penn Yan, NY, The Nest Egg sits exactly where you’d expect a beloved hometown shop to be — in the warm heart of downtown, where locals stroll, visitors linger, and the village hums with its own quiet nostalgia.
Over the years, I’ve wandered those aisles countless times — for birthdays, for holidays, for sentimental “just thinking of you” gifts — and somehow, the shop always offers something I’ve never seen before.
A Little History, Woven Into Every Corner
Knowing that The Nest Egg has been a Main Street mainstay since 1988 makes its continued magic feel even more special. Back when the world was a bit simpler and Penn Yan’s Main Street had a very different rhythm, this little gift shop opened its doors with the idea of providing something unique — things you wouldn’t find in box stores, items chosen with care, and a space that felt warm and personal.
In a way, The Nest Egg has grown up with Penn Yan. It has seen seasons of change, new shops come and go, and generations of families stopping in year after year. And through all of it, it has remained constant — a trusted place for gifts, décor, and little pieces of Keuka Lake life that somehow capture the spirit of our region.
The Keuka Lake Favorites
One thing I’ve always loved — and continue to love — is how The Nest Egg carries items that feel like home. Their Keuka Lake–themed inventory is one of the highlights:
• Charming lake map home décor
• Keuka-shaped cutting boards and kitchen gifts
• Cozy mugs, towels, and ornaments that celebrate lake life
• Local-inspired keepsakes that perfectly capture the joy of summers on the water
• Thoughtful signs, décor items, and accessories that make you smile because they remind you of the shoreline, the sunsets, or the winding roads we all know so well
Whether you’re a lifelong local or a visitor who fell in love with the Finger Lakes, these pieces feel like little love notes to Keuka itself.
A Holiday Tradition, Year After Year
Every Christmas, I find myself drawn back — almost instinctively. There’s something about seeing their seasonal displays, overflowing with twinkling lights, shimmering ornaments, and old-fashioned holiday warmth, that pulls me straight into a wave of nostalgia.
You can’t help but notice the steady hum of people doing the same thing they’ve done for decades:
Choosing an ornament for a grandchild.
Finding the perfect hostess gift.
Touching the ribbons, the candles, the figurines that feel like part of Penn Yan’s holiday story.
The Nest Egg doesn’t just decorate their shop for Christmas — it becomes Christmas
.
Where Community and Memory Meet
I suppose that’s why places like this matter so much. They remind us that small towns stay vibrant not because of buildings or events alone, but because of the people and places that give us a sense of continuity.
For more than 35 years, The Nest Egg has been one of those places for Penn Yan — quietly, lovingly rooted in Main Street life. It’s where local history meets present-day joy, where traditions are formed and re-formed, and where you can always find a piece of Keuka to take home.
Whenever I walk out with a bag in hand — whether it’s a Keuka Lake ornament, a thoughtful gift, or a little something for my own kitchen — I always feel a bit lighter, a bit more connected to home.
And maybe that’s the true gift of The Nest Egg.
Not just the items on the shelf, but the feeling you carry with you long after you’ve left.
And of course, nothing beats stepping through their door at:
📍 125 Main Street, Penn Yan, NY
Some places are shops.
The Nest Egg is a memory keeper.
🌿
Notes from Keuka Roots
There’s a unique charm to shops like The Nest Egg — establishments that have subtly woven themselves into the fabric of our shared narrative here among the lakes. Each visit serves as a cherished reminder of why I am passionate about showcasing small businesses in our area. They provide not just products, but moments… memories… and gentle reminders of why Penn Yan truly feels like home.
As I walked through the shop again this week, I found myself smiling at the familiar displays, the twinkling lights, and the Keuka Lake gifts that always tug at the heart. It struck me, once more, how much these places contribute to who we are as a community. They carry our traditions, welcome our visitors, and keep Main Street glowing year after year.
Here’s to supporting the small shops that make a big difference — and to capturing the stories that bind us all together.
🌿 Stay Rooted. Stay Keuka.
#KeukaRoots #SupportLocal #PennYanNY #FingerLakesMagic
Find them on FB
