There’s something undeniably heart-warming about stepping into The Windmill Farm & Craft Market as the holiday season peeks around the corner. Before the rush of December arrives, there’s this perfect sweet spot in late fall — when the air is crisp, the wreaths are going up, and handmade Christmas magic begins to sparkle from booth to booth.
This Saturday, I am heading to The Windmill — coffee in hand, ready to wander through that wonderland wrapped in the cozy mix of cinnamon, kettle corn, and the scent of fresh pine drifting in from the parking lot. And the heart of Saturday’s stroll?
Three incredible artisan shops that make early Christmas shopping feel like stepping into a Hallmark holiday marketplace — each bursting with personality, craft, and stories waiting to be gifted.
π
Handcrafted Treasures
Handmade, heartfelt, and brimming with charm — Handcrafted Treasures is the kind of booth where you can hear Christmas carols in the back of your mind without a single speaker in sight.
Shelves are filled with thoughtfully crafted home décor, ornaments, stitched pieces, seasonal signs, and giftables that feel warm, nostalgic, and personal. There’s always something you didn’t know you needed until you see it — the perfect kitchen towel for a friend, a rustic snowman sign for your porch, or a handcrafted ornament with that “just right” homespun feel.
It’s the stop where you pick up gifts that tell a story before they’re even wrapped.
π
Grumpy Goat Pottery
If whimsy had a pottery wheel, it would live here.
Grumpy Goat Pottery delights with character — each mug, bowl, and sculpture infused with playful, earthy charm. Christmas pieces add an extra sprinkle of joy: think textured evergreen trees, rustic-glazed ornaments, woodland critters with festive flair, and mugs that practically beg to be filled with hot cocoa while you wrap presents.
It’s one of those places where every piece feels like a keepsake, made with two hands and a whole lot of heart. And nothing beats gifting something handmade from an artisan who pours personality into every swirl of clay.
π
Messy Girl Pottery
Bold. Colorful. Joyfully imperfect in all the right ways.
Messy Girl Pottery brings an energy all its own — bright glazes, quirky shapes, and a sense of fun that makes every display burst with holiday vibrance. The Christmas pieces shine: red-and-green candy-swirl bowls, whimsical ornament trios, textured trees, and mugs that look like they leapt out of a Christmas craft book in the best way.
It’s the stop where you find gifts for people who love something unique, something artsy, something that feels alive. A Messy Girl mug or serving dish instantly turns any holiday table into a cheerful celebration.
β¨
Why Early Christmas Shopping at The Windmill Just Feels Right
There’s joy in being ahead of the holiday rush — in taking a slow Saturday to wander, discover, and support local makers before the season speeds up.
At The Windmill, every purchase supports a person, a passion, a story. And wandering between booths with Christmas ideas beginning to form is one of my favorite seasonal traditions.
Today’s stroll reminded me of how special it is to choose gifts crafted by hand — gifts that carry the heart of the Finger Lakes and the warmth of the artisans who make them.
π
A Keuka Roots Closing Thought
Handmade gifts carry something store-bought treasures can’t always replicate: a sense of care, a human touch, and a story rooted right here in our community.
If you’re looking to start your Christmas shopping early — or simply want a day wrapped in holiday spirit — make a Saturday trip to The Windmill and let these three makers inspire your season.
Stay Rooted, Stay Keuka. πΏβ¨
#KeukaRoots #TheWindmillFLX #HandcraftedChristmas #ShopLocalFLX #FingerLakesMakers #ChristmasAtTheWindmill
