When Belief Finds Its Way Home

Penny Carlton • December 14, 2025

When Belief Finds Its Way Home

A Christmastime Reflection from the Heart of Keuka

 

The Christmas holiday is never truly complete for me unless I watch the timeless classic Miracle on 34th Street — the original black-and-white version, of course. Even now, decades later, I still believe in miracles. There is a timeless purity in black and white, even within the faded film. Somehow hope speaks in a whisper only our hearts can hear, yet it echoes inside us like a lullaby or a favorite old hymn — gentle, familiar, and full of truth we often forget we know.


I tend to describe life around Keuka Lake — and our anchor villages of Hammondsport and Penn Yan — as wrapped in the kind of magic you’d expect to find only in storybooks or Hallmark movies. But sitting here today, watching that old film and feeling its quiet message settle over me, I realize something important.


Maybe, just maybe ... it isn’t magic at all.


Maybe it’s miracles — small and large, ordinary and extraordinary — arriving just when we need them, as if Kris Kringle himself placed them along our paths.


And truth be told, I wouldn’t be surprised if I passed Kris Kringle himself as he strolls down Main Street or around Pulteney Square — offering a tip of his hat, a nod of his head, and that all-knowing wink. I often wonder how many shops or homes he’s slipped into, leaving his cane propped against a fireplace or holding court near the door, just waiting to be noticed by someone who still believes.


Around Keuka, these miracles aren’t rare. They’re woven into the rhythm of our daily lives, tucked between the lakeshore sunrise and the church bells on a snowy evening. They rise from the stories we share, the hands we hold, and the hearts that continue to give — year after year.


Miracles in the way neighbors check on one another.

Miracles in the glow of a Main Street window dressed for the season.

Miracles in small-town kindness that shows up before you even ask.

Miracles in the laughter drifting from shop doors, around tables, and holiday concerts.

Miracles in the simple act of knowing you belong to a place — and it belongs to you.


To those who call Keuka home — whether along the north shore or the south — know that the magic with its holiday cheer, glitter, and jingle bells is merely a celebration of the miracles that appear all year long.


These aren’t grand gestures or cinematic moments. They’re quiet, steady reminders — the kind that slip into your day like a soft whisper or a warm memory — that we live in a corner of the world where goodness still has roots, where community still matters, and where belief isn’t something reserved for Christmas movies at all.


It lives here, every day, in a thousand small ways.


A Final Note of Gratitude


As this season wraps itself around us with its soft glow and sweet familiar comforts, my heart is full of gratitude for all of you — the neighbors who wave from porches, the shopkeepers who brighten our days, the families who fill our towns with laughter, and every soul who helps keep the spirit of Keuka alive and rooted in kindness.


Thank you for believing in the stories we share, the traditions we honor, and the sense of community that binds us together like a well-loved quilt passed through generations.

From my heart to yours, may your Christmas be filled with warmth, wonder, and the quiet miracles that appear when we least expect them — the kind that linger long after the last strand of tinsel is tucked away.



Merry Christmas, from Keuka Roots.

Stay Rooted. Stay Keuka. I believe.

By Penny Carlton February 20, 2026
Esperanza: A House Built on Hope The 1838 Keuka Lake mansion that lived a dozen lives — and still watches over the water
By Penny Carlton February 19, 2026
Cold rows, warm memories, and growing up along Keuka Lake in the late ’60s and early ’70s
By Penny Carlton February 18, 2026
The forgotten decades when the James M. Cole Circus wintered in Yates County — and farm country held the extraordinary.
By Penny Carlton February 17, 2026
When the Lake Was the Highway Transportation between Hammondsport and Penn Yan in the 1800s
By Penny Carlton February 16, 2026
The Bell, The Lights, and The Lake When the Trolley Carried Penn Yan to Brandy Bay’s Electric Park 🌿⚡
By Penny Carlton February 13, 2026
The Keuka Restaurant: A Finger Lakes Favorite for 70+ Years
By Penny Carlton February 12, 2026
The Hammondsport Winter Stroll Where winter glows instead of chills
By Penny Carlton February 11, 2026
The History of Wine Around Keuka Lake 🍇 How a crooked lake helped shape American wine
By Penny Carlton February 10, 2026
Planting Forever Roots: The Story of Oak & Anchor Inn More than a B&B — a gentle haven rooted in community, comfort, and Keuka charm.
By Penny Carlton January 28, 2026
Red Wing Bar & Chill: Where Hammondsport Unwinds
Show More